Notes on Observations
The Behavioral Science group (co-PIs Michael
D. Cohen, School of Public Policy and Thomas
Finholt, Psychology along with doctoral students Elizabeth Yakel and
Stephane Cote) of the Medical Collaboratory Project continues to study the
different potential user communities (radiologists and primary care physicians)
involved in the grant. This is being done through several different activities:
- Baseline data collection in Ultrasound and in Chest (In-Patient and
ICU) has been completed. This data which focuses on radiological practice
and consultations with primary care physicians and clinicians from the radiological
side. During the baseline data collection process we actually gained access
to and made observations in four different radiological services: ultrasound,
in-patient bone, out-patient bone, and chest. Additionally, we have made
some limited observations in magnetic resonance imaging and computed tomography.
The ultrasound and chest data, in particular, is rich in consultation instances
between clinicians/primary care physicians and radiologists.
- Data analysis has also begun. This process includes: indexing the data
(using C-Video software), extracting significant scenes, and writing up
important elements for consideration in designing the first prototypes of
the new system. All of the baseline videotape of the radiological services
has been reviewed and an initial index has been completed. Beginning in
January, a masters' student at the University of Michigan will investigate
ways of better accessing and indexing our videotapes.
- The data that we have collected is in the form of written notes and
videotapes which document a variety of routine activities as well as exception
handling in these areas. The data results from over 100 hours of observation
which resulted in 45 hours of videotaped information.
- A detailed codebook has been completed in order to better extract and
analyze significant variables from the videotapes. Coding of the initial
radiological data will be ready for statistical analysis in January.
- Negotiations have been initiated with clinicians and primary care physicians
in order to observe how this group interacts with radiological images and
reports and to analyze their consultation patterns with radiologists.
- Several interviews with clinicians have been done and we have completed
35 hours of observations of primary care physicians. At that point, we are
beginning to analyze radiological usage and patterns of use by clinicians
and primary care physicians. This is giving us a better understanding of
each of the major user groups who will utilize the new system.
Other project-related activities are occurring on a continuing basis. The
behavioral science team continues to provide feedback and discuss aspects
of radiological practice with the entire group of radiologists, behavioral
scientists, and computer scientists.
- In November 1995, an hour long documentary of radiological practice
was produced. This combined excerpts from our videotaped data and combined
with a narrated script which identified important elements for the engineers
to consider in their system design.
- A similar documentary of practice in the clinics is being developed
from over 35 hours of video and observations of the primary care physicians.
- Team members Finholt, Cote, and Yakel also attended the Radiological
Society of North America convention in Chicago, IL to see view new systems
for the interpretation and dissemination of radiological images and to assess
the degree of user input into these systems.
- An exhaustive literature search has been completed and over 200 books
and articles on radiological practice (including interpretation of images),
radiologist-clinician consultation, sociological studies of radiologists
is now analyzed and has been entered into a database.
[Description contributed by Beth Yakel, December 14, 1995.]
This page last modified on December 14, 1995. Terry
E Weymouth.
weymouth@umich.edu